This post first appeared on Mockingbird.
I’m a musical theatre kid—well, was. Kind of, anyway.
I dubbed myself a “double threat” back in my performing days. Note the double, because while I could act and sing well enough, I am a terrible dancer. So bad that when I was a senior in high school, at the end-of-year drama club banquet I received the mostly good-natured but definitely mocking “twinkle toes” award. So bad that in my college theatre program, my rail-thin, fake-blonde, leather-skinned dance instructor whose teeth were stained yellow from the cigarettes she was always trying to convince the girls to smoke to lose weight, told me in ballet class one day, “Katie, why don’t you move to the back barre, hmmm?”
All this to say, I was definitely in the target demographic for the Wicked films—someone for whom musicals aren’t an eye-roll or a novelty, but an art form I have always enjoyed, even if I was never going to become a Broadway star myself. Still, I’d always thought of myself as the kind of theatre kid who preferred Sondheim to Schwartz: complex, adult, morally ambiguous work over the popcorn energy of big-budget blockbusters.
Yet when the first Wicked film came out last year, it captivated me. Possibly because I haven’t stepped on stage in years and no longer have to worry about the pretensions of being a 20-something artiste. But also because I’m middle-aged now, and there’s enough adult complexity and moral ambiguity in my everyday life. Sometimes it’s okay to escape into spectacle. Sometimes we need it.
Which isn’t to say that the Wicked films are all spectacle for spectacle’s sake. At the heart of the story is a deep female friendship, the kind that most women I know have experienced at least once—a sweeping, all-encompassing connection where you share your darkest secrets and bare your deepest pain, simply for the intoxication of being seen and loved. It can feel almost as primal as romantic love, a risk of self-concept: can you know this much about me and still accept me? In the most fulfilling female friendships, the answer is yes—which leaves you simultaneously more capable of self-acceptance and more vulnerable to heartbreak in a way that isn’t as clean as a romantic rift. (Indeed, the most devastating breakup of my life was with a friend.)
Wicked is about that, and it’s also about the ways we hurt and disappoint each other, even when we’re trying to be good. In the first film, Elphaba is clear-eyed about right and wrong and pursues it with the sort of straightforwardness that comes from naivete: she believes that everyone will see what is good and follow through with it, if only they have it pointed out to them.
Glinda, on the other hand, is much more interested in appearing good than being good. In “Popular,” her signature song that is the stuff of middle school musical auditions everywhere, she implores Elphaba to think of “celebrated heads of state or especially great communicators. Did they have brains or knowledge? Don’t make me laugh. They were popular.”
This difference in the way they relate to the world—Elphaba as true believer and Glinda as political operative—stretches their friendship to the breaking point. In the face of an oppressive regime, Elphaba gets scapegoated as public enemy number one while Glinda is elevated as a national hero. It would be easy to read this simplistically: Elphaba gets called wicked, even though she’s trying to do good; Glinda gets called good, even though she’s colluding with evil—isn’t it sad how often we do that?
Yet the second film complicates the narrative. Elphaba discovers that even her best-intentioned plans lead to disastrous results for the people she loves and those she is most trying to help. In “No Good Deed,” my favorite song in the show, Elphaba sings: “One question haunts and hurts, too much, too much to mention. Was I really seeking good, or just seeking attention? Is that all good deeds are when looked at with an ice-cold eye? If that’s all good deeds are, maybe that’s the reason why no good deed goes unpunished.”
At the same time, Glinda discovers that her political connections and savvy put her in a position to be genuinely helpful. She banishes the wizard, prosecutes the regime’s worst offenders, and restores justice in Oz.
In the end, Elphaba is not an effective agent of change. She is too ideological and polarizing. Glinda, with her moral compromises and false smiles, is the one who makes the biggest social impact—yet, in a bittersweet twist of the knife, also ends up alone. The friend who colluded changes Oz for the better, while the friend who resisted ends up in exile. Neither resolution is straightforwardly satisfying.
This is a hard word for those of us who seek comfort in self-justification, in the lie that either our intentions or our outcomes are sufficient to be good. We are a tangled mess of mixed motivations, unintended consequences, and the heartache that comes from being in emotional proximity with other people. Those words in Elphaba’s song—“no good deed goes unpunished”—is not a pronouncement of intent as much as it is an observation of the intractable nature of sin: good deeds do not actually exist, so we can’t rely on them to escape punishment.
If this sounds bleak, good: it is the law holding up a mirror to ourselves and forcing us to confront the awful reality that our best efforts will never be enough.
But there is good news here, too.
In the story’s final act, our flawed and broken heroines find their way back to each other. In the way the closest female friends do, they see each other, forgive each other, love each other—in and through the hurt they have inflicted on each other. It is a love that is neither earned nor deserved, which is why it is grace.
What we are left with is hope, not that goodness is possible this side of the eschaton, but that love is, and friendship is, and reconciliation is—and maybe that’s all we need to be changed for good.
